★ 5.0 on Google · No long contracts · You own every asset
Rathly

Why do rankings drop, and how do you diagnose the cause?

Short answer

Rankings drop for a few common reasons. A technical problem blocks Google, or a core update changes how Google judges pages. Competitors improve, demand shifts with the season or a site change breaks something. Rarely, it is a manual action. Search Console and a timeline of recent changes usually show which one.

In this answer
  1. 01The usual causes
  2. 02How to diagnose a drop
  3. 03If a core update caused it
  4. 04If your site caused it

The usual causes

CauseTypical signWhere to look
Technical problemPages vanish or traffic falls off a cliffPage indexing report and URL Inspection
Algorithm updateA gradual drop that lines up with an updateGoogle Search Status Dashboard
CompetitorsYou slip a few places on key termsThe current results for those searches
Seasonal demandImpressions fall but positions holdSearch Console, compared year over year
Site changeThe drop starts right after a launch or editYour change log and redirects
Manual actionSudden losses plus a message from GoogleManual actions report

How to diagnose a drop

  1. Pin down the date the drop started in Search Console.
  2. Check whether impressions fell, or only positions or clicks.
  3. Compare the date with the Search Status Dashboard.
  4. List every site change from the week before.
  5. Find which pages and queries lost the most.

Google's guide to traffic drops also mentions reporting glitches. Check Search Console's data anomalies page before you change anything.

If a core update caused it

Google says a drop after a core update does not mean something is fundamentally wrong with your content. Compare your pages with the ones that gained. Improve usefulness, proof and clarity on the pages that lost, rather than making quick technical tweaks.

If your site caused it

Good example. A dental office notices a drop two days after a redesign. It finds that old URLs lost their redirects, restores them and recovers within weeks.

Bad example. The same office rewrites every page in a panic after a small seasonal dip and makes the drop worse.

Changes in demand are not losses. A pool company sees fewer impressions every winter because fewer people search.

See SEO penalties and why pages are not indexed. Our SEO audit finds the cause before anyone touches the site.

Keep reading

Related answers

All SEO questions →

Your agency isn't delivering? Talk to us.

  • ✓ You talk to the people who do the work
  • ✓ We handle 95% of requests the same or next day
  • ✓ You own every account, site and listing
Talk to usSTEP 1 OF 2
What isn't working?
No contract. Cloudflare Turnstile blocks spam.
Call usTalk to us →