★ 5.0 on Google · No long contracts · You own every asset
Rathly

What SEO metrics should you track?

Short answer

Track the metrics that connect search to revenue. Watch impressions, clicks and the queries you rank for in Search Console. Track calls, forms and bookings from organic visits in GA4 and call tracking. Add map pack actions from your Business Profile, then the leads and sales they turn into. Rankings alone mislead.

In this answer
  1. 01Metrics at each stage
  2. 02The metrics we report every month
  3. 03Metrics that mislead on their own
  4. 04Set up tracking before you judge SEO

Metrics at each stage

SEO metrics from visibility to revenue
  1. VisibilityImpressions, queries and average position in Search Console.
  2. VisitsOrganic clicks and engaged sessions in GA4.
  3. LeadsCalls, forms and bookings tracked as key events.
  4. RevenueLeads that became paying customers in your CRM.

Each stage explains the one below it. Rising impressions with flat clicks point to weak titles. Rising clicks with flat leads point to the page itself.

The metrics we report every month

MetricWhere to find itWhat it tells you
Impressions and clicksSearch Console Performance reportWhether Google shows you and people choose you
Queries and pagesSearch Console Performance reportWhich searches and pages bring the visits
Organic key eventsGA4, filtered to organic searchCalls, forms and bookings from SEO
Profile actionsBusiness Profile performanceCalls, direction requests and website clicks
Indexed pagesSearch Console Page indexing reportWhether your important pages can rank at all
Leads and salesYour CRM or call logWhat SEO is actually worth

Metrics that mislead on their own

  • Average position. It blends hundreds of queries into one number.
  • Total traffic. Visitors from outside your area never buy.
  • Domain scores. Tool ratings that Google does not use.
  • One ranking check. Map results change from street to street.

Set up tracking before you judge SEO

Mark calls, form submissions and bookings as key events in GA4. Use call tracking numbers on the website, and keep your main number on your listings. Without this setup, an SEO report can only show traffic, never the leads behind it.

See the tools for measuring SEO. Our SEO services report leads and revenue, not just rankings.

Keep reading

Related answers

All SEO questions →

Your agency isn't delivering? Talk to us.

  • ✓ You talk to the people who do the work
  • ✓ We handle 95% of requests the same or next day
  • ✓ You own every account, site and listing
Talk to usSTEP 1 OF 2
What isn't working?
No contract. Cloudflare Turnstile blocks spam.
Call usTalk to us →